by Stephen A. Wandner and Christopher J. O’Leary
March 12, 2020
The COVID-19 virus is likely to cause major disruptions in U.S. labor markets for at least 18 months—until a vaccine is developed and widely administered. Any program to help affected workers and stimulate the U.S. economy should be carefully targeted to workers who are most in need of income support and most likely to quickly spend these funds in the local economy.
Four groups of workers will most likely suffer severe problems during the COVID-19 crisis:
- Sick individuals whose jobs do not provide sick leave or sufficient sick leave.
- Unemployed workers who are covered by unemployment insurance (UI) but are deemed ineligible because they do not satisfy the requirements for being able to, being available for, and actively seeking work, among other eligibility requirements.
- Unemployed workers who receive UI benefits but have exhausted their regular UI benefits.
- Workers not covered by the UI program, including the self-employed, contract employees, and, more generally, “gig workers.”
These groups may all suffer earnings losses because of illness, public health requirements for social distancing from co-workers or customers during the crisis, and declines in economic demand for the products and services they provide. They may lose labor income, be ineligible for UI, or exhaust their benefits. Unless they have substantial savings, they will be unable to pay for basic needs—food, rent, medical care, car payments—for themselves and their families. Their decreased spending will also harm their local economies.
We propose changes to UI programs to provide income to covered unemployed workers, to workers still technically employed but without sick leave, and to those unemployed but not covered by UI. Specifically, two packages of UI initiatives should be undertaken, with each limited to an 18-month time frame.
COVID-19 Unemployment Insurance Program Refinements
- Access to Benefits: States should simplify the UI application process and provide telephone support to UI applicants who have difficulty applying for benefits.
- Able and Available: Workers suffering from COVID-19 or in a required recovery quarantine should have the “able and available” work requirements to receive UI waived.
- Actively Seeking Work: Unemployed workers from jobs that do not permit sufficient social distancing from co-workers and customers should have UI’s work search requirements lifted. Workers allowed to telecommute must continue to work.
- Benefit Standards: All states should be required to offer benefits for a potential duration of at least 26 weeks, and the maximum weekly benefit amount should be two-thirds of the average weekly wage among UI-covered workers in that state.
- Administration: The federal government should substantially increase grants to states to pay for the administration of state UI programs, as well as a new COVID-19 Special Unemployment Assistance program (see below).
- Temporary Emergency Compensation: A temporary emergency compensation program extending the duration of benefits for 26 weeks should be made available to all UI recipients, in all states, regardless of the unemployment rate. It should be enacted by Congress and paid for from federal general revenue.
- Permanent Extended Benefits: Extended benefits should be federalized and paid from federal general revenue. This would provide up to 13 weeks of additional UI benefits when the state total unemployment rate is above 5 percent in the preceding month.
COVID-19 Special Unemployment Assistance
During the severe 1974-1975 recession Congress enacted a Special Unemployment Assistance (SUA) program that paid benefits to workers not covered by the regular UI program. The program was temporary and paid with federal general revenue. A similar temporary program could be created to pay unemployment assistance to workers who become sick from COVID-19 or have been laid off because they were employed in jobs that prevent social distancing and either 1) don’t have or have exhausted their sick leave or 2) who become unemployed and work in uncovered employment. SUA benefits would:
- Be payable to self-employed, contract, and gig economy workers.
- Be payable for up to 52 weeks.
- Be paid using state benefit formulas but with crisis enhancements to amounts and durations listed above.
- Determine monetary eligibility by payroll or tax filing records.
- Waive “able, available, and actively seeking work” requirements as described above.
- Ensure benefit access by having state UI staff assist with the SUA application, whether this be a new process or adapted from the Disaster Unemployment Assistance program.
The temporary UI program refinements and COVID-19 SUA program would together provide income support to the great majority of workers adversely affected by the COVID-19 economic shock. State UI programs across the country are uniquely suited to enroll new participants in income transfer payment programs, process weekly or biweekly cash payments, and rapidly establish programs in times of emergencies. State UI agencies have experience with Disaster Unemployment Assistance, the 9/11 airline unemployment assistance program, and temporary emergency compensation programs during recessions.
More Upjohn Institute COVID-19 responses
- "Preserving Jobs Despite the Coronavirus: Encouraging 'Labor Hoarding'" by Timothy J. Bartik
- "Coronavirus and the Economy: Repurposing Production, Helping the Needy, Saving Businesses, and Encouraging Job Preservation" by Timothy J. Bartik and Brad Hershbein
- "Shared-Work Programs Can Ease the Coronavirus’s Economic Impact" by Katharine Abraham and Susan N. Houseman
- "Disaster Unemployment Assistance would help gig, contract, self-employed workers affected by COVID-19" by Stephen A. Woodbury
- "What is the likely impact of proposed COVID-19 stimulus payments?" by Marta Lachowska
- Stimulus steps the US should take to reduce regional economic damages from the COVID-19 recession, by Timothy J. Bartik, Brad Hershbein, Mark Muro and Bryan A. Stuart (Brookings)
- "Housing policy is crucial to stem the coronavirus fallout" by Lee Adams, Brian Asquith and Evan Mast.